You can determine the value of your coins. Auction results and images of one the finest know 1899 pennies is detailed below. Rare in this condition and considered the most desirable as a collectible, values can reach into the hundreds of dollars. You can see LIBERTY is clearly visible as part of the headband. Pictured is an 1899 Indian penny in 'uncirculated' condition, this coin never entered circulation and fortunately remains as minted. If parts of 'LIBERTY' are visible the coin is in better condition than most and of higher value. Look closely at the headband on you coin, just above her eye. Old pennies that circulated to the point their design is only an outline are worth in the $1 to 2 dollar range.
Condition is key to how much your Indian penny is worth.